Wrong doing - What's your ultimate goal?

I saw a post this morning begging for forgiveness from the Hive community. https://hive.blog/appeals/@jahangir1/my-hivewatchers-blacklist-appeal-day-5 We've all seen these types of posts before and while I'd love to get into the whole:
1. Why is there not just one self appointed Hive police force?

2. Why is it so hard to get your name cleared?
I already know some of the stock answers.

Now before I go any further, I only read the post, I did not drill down any further in terms of information or data but what I will say is twelve posts that supposedly contain plagiarism and or other content that falls foul of the likes of Hivewatchers and Cheetah is a tad more than just "Simple Human Error" even in my estimation it comes across as willful and I'm also not convinced by the perceived language barrier either. Google has a reasonably good Translator as does the Internet.

The question is probably the same question society asks: What is the ultimate goal of punishment? Is it purely they to inflict suffering on the perpetrator with little or no chance of redemption? Or is it there to say: You and I know you did wrong, we punished you as a deterrent to you and others, now lets see how we can put you on the right path."

You choose?

Rehabilitation - Let's work with them to bring them back into the community.

Revenge - Take everything from them, kick them out! Hound them!

Freedom - Surely Freedom means people should be able to do what they like?

Answer the question at dpoll.xyz.